• trickylens
    14 days ago

    Right. So God is both benevolent and all seeing and all powerful, but doesn't intervene when children are being abused, or people are in horrible pain, and animals are being eaten alive, and stuff, because he wants us all to have free will. And the pope is the voice of God on earth, right?

    ....but he's voted for by a bunch of repressive old boomers, many of whom are quite clearly off their trollies. Who presumably have free will, because that's what god wants right?

    So how do they always happen to vote for the right one, who is actually the voice of God, and not some Robert Jenrick-a-like?

  • Seanlens
    10 days ago

    When did everyone start saying 'whilst' instead of 'while' in text form?

    I mean, I know it's grammatically valid and correct and all that but it's something I've suddenly started noticing more and more, pretty much everywhere.

    It just scans as, kind of jarringly weird and inappropriately formal for some reason. No one actually says it verbally. Just in written form.

    I'm sure it was never always thus and is a fairly new thing.

  • Charliepanorama_fish_eye
    10 days ago

    While is a more contemporary and 'friendly' word than whilst, which fairly or not has connotations of thee, thou, amidst, amongst etc - ie: old fashioned, a bit frumpy and stuffy. For context, I'm a commercial writer and it's one of my jobs to make dull stuff understandable, approachable etc. And I'll still always use 'while'.

    However, as you say, whilst seems to have been gaining in popularity. I reckon it's to do with some people wanting to appear a bit posher and better educated than they are, and see the use of arcane language as a weird step in that direction. The best example I can think of right now is the prevalence of myself and yourself instead of me and you, which drives me crazy.

  • trickylens
    10 days ago

    Whilst I take the point, in my mind the former is in the declarative/abstract, while the latter is more first person inclusive.

    As ever, I may be wrong.

  • BrettWilliamspanorama_fish_eye
    10 days ago

    As sub-editors, we were told to change any instances of 'whilst' to 'while' in our newspaper style guide and I've been doing the same ever since. I left the industry nearly 11 years ago.

    That's all I've got, I'm afraid.

  • Seanlens
    10 days ago

    Good. Glad it's not just me.

  • Resident_Alienpanorama_fish_eye
    9 days ago

    I think it also got a popularity bump as something of a meme-ish piss-take of people using it to sound intellectual. I’ve seen it used a lot that way, anyway.
    See also: ‘M’lady’ to make fun of incels.

Search
  • Enter search query (at least 3 characters).

Your options